The Dramatic Landscape of the Northwest and Islands of Scotland
Scotland | Sep 6 - Sep 23, 2026

Holly
Holly M.
Chapel Hill, NC | Reviewed on Sep 24, 2026

We had an amazing 18-day trip focused on the NC500, the Outer Hebrides, the Highlands and Islay. We enjoyed spectacular scenery, historic landmarks, iconic hotels, and activities that fit our interests to a T.
In particular, the itinerary fit perfectly with our interests and we liked that we could choose from among options along the way.
We had three guides--at the Torridon Hotel a guide, whose name I didn't quite catch, took us on a nature hike that was spectacular, Donald Mathheson toured us around Lewis and Harris (2 days), and Dougie Mac Taggert took us on a lengthy coastal walk, escorted us to our Tour at the Kilchoman Distillery and ended with a walk through the RSPB Loch Gruinart. All were exceptional and very personable to spend a morning or day with.
We covered a lot of ground either on foot, in the car, or by ferry.

Hotel Reviews
Rocpool Reserve
Inverness

We only had a one-night stay at the Rocpool Reserve. The room was very attractive and unique in that the bathroom was downstairs from the bedroom. The bathroom was the most spacious I've ever encountered! Going downstairs when nature calls in the middle of the night might not be to everyone's liking. Other rooms may not have this same configuration. It was in a convenient location for us to explore Inverness on the afternoon of our arrival. Breakfast in the morning was excellent.

Authenticity & Character
The room configuration was certainly unique. Primarily, the decor is quite lovely.
Location
It's a relatively short walk to the center of Inverness. It is quite hilly and depending on where your wanderings in town take you, the walk back to the hotel can be a bit steep.
Staff
As our stay was quite short, our interactions with the staff were quite few, but all that we encountered were gracious and friendly.
Cleanliness & Comfort
Forss House
Thurso

Forss House is tucked away in the woods off the main highway. The main house has 4 or 5 rooms and there are also cottages, popular with the fishing crowd. Our room in the main house was spacious and comfortable. For dining, there is a dining room and a conservatory (a glassed-in porch) which was especially nice for breakfast. We had dinner at the hotel that was orchestrated very well. We began in the Bar where we were served Champagne and hors d'oeuvres. Then went into the dining room for dinner. The food was exceptional. We wandered the grounds and enjoyed the waterfall and the meandering river. The gardens around the house are lovely.

Authenticity & Character
The grounds and decor.
Location
It's off the main highway and surrounded by woods.
Staff
Cleanliness & Comfort
Good pillows!
Scourie Hotel
Scourie

Perfectly nice hotel. Room was on the small side. Lobby and public areas make it clear that this area is ideal for fishing.

Authenticity & Character
As mentioned above, the public spaces in the hotel make it clear that the area has good fishing.
Location
This is close to Handa Island. Unfortunately, we did not get to experience it as the weather did not cooperate.
Staff
Cleanliness & Comfort
The Dipping Lugger
Ullapool

Our room was absolutely gorgeous. It felt more like a suite with a small hallway leading off the bedroom to the spacious bathroom that had both a shower and free-standing bathtub. The food is amazing. We had 2 dinners and 2 breakfasts there. Dinner is a series of small courses which can be paired with wines for each course. Unique to this hotel is that breakfast is fixed and presented as small courses much like as the dinner. but with breakfast type food/dishes. No wine at breakfast!

Authenticity & Character
Absolutely gorgeous inside and out.
Location
It is located on the Ullapool waterfront and very close to the ferry terminal/dock. There are interesting sites and attractions nearby.
Staff
The staff is very welcoming and personable.
Cleanliness & Comfort
Broad Bay House
Back

Broad Bay House is located 15 minutes north of Stornoway and was built to be a Bed and Breakfast rather than converting a private home to such. On our first night's stay we enjoyed a sharing platter of seafood for dinner. It was ample, attractively presented, and very good. On specific nights they serve a plated dinner but our stay didn't coincide with this option,

Authenticity & Character
The guest rooms are toward the front of the house. The social space includes a dining area and comfortable furniture for relaxing. It is nicely decorated throughtout.
Location
It sits atop a cliff and overlooks the broad bay and beach. There is access to the beach quite near the house, We enjoyed walking on the beach at low tide.
Staff
We had some delightful conversations with the owner.
Cleanliness & Comfort
Great bathroom!
Marmalade Hotel
Portree

We had a very brief stay from early evening to early morning as we were transitioning from our stay on Harris and Lewis to heading towards the Applecross penninsula.

Authenticity & Character
It was very attractive.
Location
Convenient to the center of Portree. We were able to walk to a restaurant for dinner in 8 minutes. Parking can be challenging in town.
Staff
We only interacted with the person on duty when we checked in/out and the person who served us breakfast.
Cleanliness & Comfort
The Torridon
Achnasheen

This was quite exceptional between the stately, elegant stone building, the carriage houses, and the property with walking trails.

Authenticity & Character
The hotel building is stunning as are the grounds.
Location
Absolutely gorgeous! Lovely forest, loch, bar, restaurant, rooms!
Staff
Very friendly.
Cleanliness & Comfort
The bath towels!!! I have never experienced such fluffy towels!
Isle of Eriska Hotel
Benderloch

As we only had one night's stay, it's a bit harder to rate this hotel in its entirety. We didn't take advantage of the spa. We had dinner in the more casual restaurant, the Deck. We did wander around the island and enjoyed the views and encounters with both farm and wildlife. Our room was a bit on the small side and quite a climb to via a steep stairway.

Authenticity & Character
The hotel looks castle-ish and the interior is evocative of a manor home (not that I've ever lived in one).
Location
It is in a gorgeous setting, a private island. It's best enjoyed with a stay of a few nights to take advantage of all the activities to be had.
Staff
With just a one-night stay we can only comment on the staff who checked us in and out. the Deck restaurant staff, and our breakfast server. All were helpful and gracious.
Cleanliness & Comfort
The usual sparkling clean room and bath!
Port Charlotte Hotel
Isle of Islay

Our room was okay and the bathroom quite small. It took a very long time for the shower to get hot water. PIllows were not very "fluffy" but we had been spoiled by previous hotels on this trip. By the same token, the more simple accommodation was just fine and seemed completely suited to the locale and flavor of Port Charlotte in a good way.

Authenticity & Character
The character seemed so authentic to the place and was clearly a popular dining venue with the locals. We arrived in the evening and the place was lively with people at the bar and restaurant, a change from the prior hotels that seemed to be mostly US tourists such as ourselves.
Location
The hotel is right on the waterfront which always makes me happy.
Staff
The woman who checked us in (the owner?) was very helpful and friendly with a good sense of humor.
Cleanliness & Comfort
One star removed for disappointing pillows.
The Loch Lomond Arms Hotel

With only a stay of about 17 hours, it is difficult to give much detail. Nevertheless, the interior had recently been updated and highlighted the interests, hobbies, and personalities of members of the Colcuhoun family who have been in the luss area for centuries.

Authenticity & Character
There are lots of details in the decor (guest room names, stuffed mountain lion on the landing up to our room, maps, taxidermized birds in cases in the bar, etc) Very atmospheric!
Location
Right on the shores of Loch Lomond, we had a nice stroll around Luss after we arrived. Quite the lovely spot. Had we been staying longer this is in a convenient location to explore Loch Lomond.
Staff
Because we were leaving in the morning before breakfast was served, the staff arranged for us to get a to do breakfast roll.
Cleanliness & Comfort
We had a small room on the top floor for our one-night stay which was fine. Again, lots of details to notice.
Activity Reviews
RSPB Dunnet Head
RSPB Dunnet Head
Thurso

We had good weather although the wind was blowing furiously. We were past the seabird nesting time but saw a number of seabirds flying about. It's worth the walk to see the stacks.

Quality of Experience
Drive, NC500 Thurso to Scourie
Drive, NC500 Thurso to Scourie
Scotland

Single track roads galore. Two great stops: Strathnaber Museum (the story of the clearances told well) and Smoo Cave (wild to see a river disappear into a cave).

Quality of Experience
The beauty of the coast drive was the hightlight.
Welcome to Ullapool
Welcome to Ullapool
Ullapool

Ullapool is a nice town that occasionally gets cruise ships so the shopping along the waterfront is geared to tourism. The shops are more reasonable and of strictly local fare than some cruise ports we've experienced. From Ullapool we visited the Corrieshalloch Gorge and Nature Reserve which is a must see.

Loch na Muilne
Loch na Muilne
Lewis

Took a look. Pretty but did not blow our socks off (even the though the wind was blowing hard enough to do so).

The Summer Isles Boat Trip
The Summer Isles Boat Trip
Scotland

The Summer Isles Boat Trip had to be canceled due to rough winds and water, but we were able to go on the Whale and Dolphin cruise later in the afternoon in a high-speed RIB boat. No whales spotted but playful dolphins kept us entertained. We also saw Common Seals resting on the rocks.

Quality of Experience
They provide a suit and safety instructions.
Guides, Drivers and Staff
Very knowledgable.
Transport
Fun ride on the RIB boat!
Half Day Guided Hike: Torridon Resort
Half Day Guided Hike: Torridon Resort
Torridon

This was exceptional. Our guide took us on a wonderful hike on the Shieldaig Penninsula. We learned a lot and we quite on the same page in terms of interests and what mattered most to us.

Quality of Experience
Taking a spectacular trail we would never have found on our own.
Guides, Drivers and Staff
Our guide was very knowledgeable and a joy to spend a morning with.
Transport
Lewis Tour with Guide
Lewis Tour with Guide
Lewis

We were picked up at our B&B at 10 am and proceeded to the very northern tip of the island to see the lighthouse and the dramatic cliffs in strong winds. From there we made a brief stop at the Port of Ness, formerly a herring fishing port. Next we visited a small, but mighty museum, Comunn Eachdraidh Nis that highlights the local history. A small cafe provided a delicious lunch. Moving down the west coast, we visited the Clach An Truishal Standing Stone, The Shieling Barvas and Brue, Whalebone Arch, Gearrannan Blackhouse Village, a Harris Tweed factory, and Dun Carloway Broch.

Quality of Experience
By the end of the day we felt we knew what Lewis was and is all about.
Guides, Drivers and Staff
Donald was the perfect guide.
Transport
We rode in Donald's taxi which was perfectly comfortable for the day's drive.
Harris Tour with Guide
Harris Tour with Guide
Scotland

Day 2 with our driver, Donald, we toured around the coast of Harris. Because it is so mountainous, there isn't the same level of historic sights as on Lewis. The one historical site is St. Clement's Church with 15th century carvings and graves within. The west coast of Harris offered beautiful beaches.

Quality of Experience
Beautiful scenery!
Guides, Drivers and Staff
Donald is the best!
Transport
Corrieshalloch Gorge National Nature Reserve
Corrieshalloch Gorge National Nature Reserve
Ullapool

This was well worth a visit. We were fortunate to get good weather (meaning only a little rain). I highly recommend this reserve. As we are birdwatchers, we did have some nice birding along the Fern Walk. Combined with the path to the suspension bridge across the gorge, it makes for a long enough walk to work of that morning porridge with cream and honey.

Quality of Experience
Simply gorgeous
Kilchoman Distillery Classic Tour
Kilchoman Distillery Classic Tour
Islay

Even though I'm not much of a whisky drinker, this tour was very well done. Very cleverly, they provide everyone (except the designated driver) a lanyard that supports a whisky tasking glass. As the tour progressed we sampled whiskies along the way.

Quality of Experience
We had an excellent lunch in the cafe before the tour. I highly recommend it.
Guides, Drivers and Staff
Very informative tour leader.
Local specialist: Eleanor Whitticombe
Eleanor
Eleanor Whitticombe
Local specialist in Pembrokeshire, Wales | Replied on Sep 25, 2026
Dear Holly,
Thank you for sharing your experience. It’s wonderful to hear that the route through the northwest, Outer Hebrides and Islay suited your interests so well, and that you enjoyed the freedom to choose what to explore along the way.
I’m especially pleased that your walks and time with Donald and Dougie were highlights. I’ll pass your kind words on to them and to the team at The Torridon.
Thank you also for the thoughtful feedback on Rocpool Reserve. I’m glad you enjoyed the room and...
Read more

Dear Holly,
Thank you for sharing your experience. It’s wonderful to hear that the route through the northwest, Outer Hebrides and Islay suited your interests so well, and that you enjoyed the freedom to choose what to explore along the way.
I’m especially pleased that your walks and time with Donald and Dougie were highlights. I’ll pass your kind words on to them and to the team at The Torridon.
Thank you also for the thoughtful feedback on Rocpool Reserve. I’m glad you enjoyed the room and breakfast, and your point about the stairs between the bedroom and bathroom is helpful when we consider which rooms to recommend.
We’re delighted you had such a memorable 18 days in Scotland.
Warm wishes,
Eleanor