We had a fabulous trip to the north and west of Scotland
Scotland | Sep 6 - Sep 23, 2026

Ross
Ross M.
Miami, FL | Reviewed on Sep 24, 2026

We had a fabulous trip to the north and west coasts of Scotland organized by Eleanor Whitticombe and her team. The trip was gorgeous and filled with memories. Several of the hotels were particularly memorable: The Dipping Lugger in Ullapool, TheTorridon, and the Isle of Eriska. Each combined superb service, a great room, and excellent meals. One of our most memorable days was on Islay, where Dougie Mac Taggert led us on a coastal hike from an old church to Kilchoman, with a short drive to the distillery for lunch and a tour. The tour was excellent and so were the sample drams we consumed during the tour (very clever). We then hiked through the RSPB Preserve at Loch Gruinart. All together memorable! But so were our full day tours of Lewis and Harris with Donald Matheson, a life long resident of Lewis. He embodied the history present on the island and made my life easy because I wasn't the one handling the single track roads. And speaking of single track roads, B869 to the Drumbeg Viewpoint and to Lochinver was gorgeous - when I could take my eyes off the road.
Basically every day was memorable and special - one of our best trips ever, and we vacation well. Thank you to Eleanor and her team!

Hotel Reviews
Rocpool Reserve
Inverness

A very nice hotel in a good location for walking to central Inverness. Our room was exotic in that the bathroom, which was large and well-equipped, was down a winding staircase from the bedroom.

Authenticity & Character
Location
Staff
Cleanliness & Comfort
Forss House
Thurso

One of those classic old manor houses. Our room was spacious and had a very comfortable sofa on which I could sit and relax. It's an odd omission, but there was no desk chair in the room, so my laptop computer really was a laptop computer. The staff was superb, the dinner excellent.

Authenticity & Character
On spacious grounds with a beautiful view of a waterfall only a short walk from the house
Location
Staff
Cleanliness & Comfort
Cleanliness was excellent. The only comfort downside was the lack of a desk chair
Scourie Hotel
Scourie

We very much enjoyed our stay at the Scourie House because the people were so nice. It's not fancy - a well maintained older hotel that was probably built as an inn. Our room wasn't that big, so suitcase space was at a premium. But what the room may have lacked in upscale fashion, the staff made up in friendliness. And the food in the restaurant was very good.

Authenticity & Character
This is the sort of hotel that seemed to have a loyal clientele who return year after year to fish ...
Location
Scourie is a small village in a beautiful part of Scotland. Take the B869 and visit the Allt Chranaidh Waterfall
Staff
Super friendly and helpful.
Cleanliness & Comfort
It was sparkling clean, but the bed and the room were somewhat small.
The Dipping Lugger
Ullapool

At every level, the Dipping Lugger is amazing. They think of everything. The room was gorgeous, the bed super-comfortable. The food was spectacular! There are only 3 rooms, but this is luxury writ large and in a comfortable, not ostentatious way. The only quirk is that they pick your meals - dinner is a fixed 7 course meal (and what a meal it is!) (the bread I will NEVER forget) and breakfast is chosen for you. It's all more than good, but maybe not what you would have picked. Just an idiosyncrasy, not a problem.

Authenticity & Character
Beautiful and well restored inn that felt timelessly grand even through small.
Location
Write on the main street of Ullapool, looking out at the harbor, and right down the street from the ferry terminal to Stornaway (our next stop).
Staff
So nice, so aware. Could not have been better.
Cleanliness & Comfort
The bed was sooooo comfortable.
Broad Bay House
Back

The Broad Bay House is a purpose-built small inn near Stornoway. Super clean and well equipped. Tom, the owner, has thought of everything any traveler could need. He has loads of material about Lewis and Harris, and has prepared a guide book that reflected his deep knowledge of the area. Breakfasts were excellent, esp. the porridge. And we had the seafood passed-plate meal for dinner one night. The location is right on the beach, and it's worth going for a walk past the sheep.

Authenticity & Character
It's really more new and clean and tidy than characterful, but very tastefully decorated.
Location
Just north of Stornoway. It's a bit isolated, but with the beach there, who cares?
Staff
Tom was full of good advice when we could grasp his accented Scottish English.
Cleanliness & Comfort
Perfectly clean, very comfortable.
The Torridon
Achnasheen

Grand in every regard. "Regal" might also fit. As characterful as the 1890s style would suggest, while still having every modern convenience. Those towels - so soft, so absorbent - and that shower. Ahhh, satisfaction. Both restaurants are excellent (Bo and Muc is more casual, 1889 a multi-course extravagance). Breakfasts are, as you would expect, very good, although our omelets were a bit under-done. We went hiking with the Torridon Outdoor Experience, and it was an excellent walk near the hotel. We also hiked the hotel grounds, which are extensive and very pretty.

Authenticity & Character
Grand elegance from another era with service at a very high level.
Location
Truly in the middle of nowhere in a good way.
Staff
They took care of everything.
Cleanliness & Comfort
Those towels..... (and everything else, but the towels were memorable)
Isle of Eriska Hotel
Benderloch

This is an elegant old manor house on a private island. The house is charming, although our room was up several flights of stairs. The room itself was well equipped and comfortable. The grounds are gorgeous and worth more than the afternoon's walk that we took. The Terrace Restaurant was quite good. Not formal and all small plates (not tapas, just small plates).

Authenticity & Character
A beautiful old house with characterful rooms.
Location
A pretty wooded private island
Staff
Very helpful.
Cleanliness & Comfort
Port Charlotte Hotel
Isle of Islay

We were in a smallish upstairs room with a fairly small double bed. There is a severe deficiency of electrical outlets for the modern traveler. We unplugged the hotels lamps and coffee pot so that we'd be able to charge phones and the like. The staff were very nice and helpful, opening for breakfast early so that we could sprint to the ferry in Port Askaig in a timely manner. The restaurant is good and locally popular. The bar, on the other hand, is a whisky lover's dream. Also popular, for good reason.

Authenticity & Character
Lots of character. And as an old, characterful hotel, smallish rooms that were a challenge for suitcases.
Location
In the center of Port Charlotte, on the water.
Staff
Cleanliness & Comfort
Cleanliness was excellent. The lack of plugs and the small bed were a bit of challenge. And the hot water took several minutes to arrive to the shower. When it arrived, it was fuly heated but easily diluted to a good shower temperature.
The Loch Lomond Arms Hotel

Lots of atmosphere and a great location adjacent to Luss and short walk to the Loch. Our room was up several flights of stairs, but the bellman was very helpful in carrying our suitcases up. A smallish room and smallish bed. The shower was powerful (loved that) and sprayed widely into the bathroom (which I didn't like). Lots of plugs, unlike some older hotels. The restaurant was good, and the bar was fine. You order in the restaurant and carry your whiskey to the library where there are chairs.

Authenticity & Character
Location
Staff
Cleanliness & Comfort
Lots of stairs to a smallish room.
Marmalade Hotel
Portree

We were at the Marmelade Hotel so briefly that I hate to say anything negative. The room was very comfortable and well equipped, and we fell asleep almost the moment we hit it. Breakfast was fine.

Authenticity & Character
We were in a modern wing of the hotel, so character wasn't a prime attribute.
Location
It's about a 10 minute walk to downtown Portree
Staff
Cleanliness & Comfort
Very clean and tidy. And very comfortable for our short stay.
Activity Reviews
The Summer Isles Boat Trip
The Summer Isles Boat Trip
Scotland

We had rough seas, so the boat trip was a blend between visiting the Summer Isles and doing dolphin and seal watching. There was a guide, but she didn't speak very often, and English wasn't the boat driver's primary language.

Quality of Experience
The boat ride was a blast, but the information content wasn't as good as it could have been. We didn't really know where we were or what we were seeing.
Guides, Drivers and Staff
They could have spoken more often, explained more.
Half Day Guided Hike: Torridon Resort
Half Day Guided Hike: Torridon Resort
Torridon

We had a great walking tour of the Shieldaig Peninsula. The guide pointed out interesting natural features as we went. I would say his knowledge of plants was greater than birds, but he did well with both (in our couple, one of is more birder, the other more a plant person). The walk was sane topographically, and quite pretty.

Quality of Experience
Guides, Drivers and Staff
Transport
Our guide drove us from the Torridon to the Shieldaig Peninsula, about 10 minutes.
Handa Island
Handa Island
Scotland

Sadly we didn't go. It was raining and most of the interesting birds have flown the coop (well, the island). However, we used the day to see the spectacular Allt Chranaidh Waterfall and breathtaking B869 to Drumbeg and Lochinver. Breathtaking both in beauty and in the twisty-turny uphill-downhill single track road. That drive would get 5 stars, so our substitution was sound from my point of view.

Quality of Experience
RSPB Dunnet Head
RSPB Dunnet Head
Thurso

By September, most of the interesting birds have wandered on. Better to spend time in John O'Groats and at Duncansby Head (spectacular!). I'll bet this is wonderful place to bird in Spring and earlier in the summer.

Quality of Experience
Drive, NC500 Thurso to Scourie
Drive, NC500 Thurso to Scourie
Scotland

The highlights on this leg were Smoo Cave (a must) and the Strathnaver Museum in Bettyhill, also a must-see. The museum tells the story of the highland clearances in a very personalized way that provides real emotional impact. The drive from Thurso to Scourie is mostly single track roads, so be psychologically prepared. And know the rules of single tracking. Too many people don't understand it.

Quality of Experience
Lewis Tour with Guide
Lewis Tour with Guide
Lewis

Our guide, Donald Matheson, was fantastic! He's a lifelong resident of Lewis, and he knew every nook and cranny, every bit of history. He was a wealth of fascinating information. This was a delightful day. We went to the north end of Lewis and worked our way back, stopping at museums, Ness Harbor, the Carloway Harris Tweed mill, black houses, and standing stones. We skipped Callanish because we had seen it the day before on our own. A completely memorable day. I highly recommend Donald as a guide.

Quality of Experience
Lewis is an amazing island, and you'll appreciate it more after a tour like this.
Guides, Drivers and Staff
Donald Matheson is a star -everything a guide should be.
Transport
Donald drives a taxi in Lewis most of the time, so single track roads are second nature. I appreciated the day off.
Harris Tour with Guide
Harris Tour with Guide
Scotland

Again, Donald Matheson was a great guide. We loved seeing Harris. Harris isn't about history the way Lewis is - it's scenery. And the scenery and beaches are beautiful. Donald was aware I'm a photographer, and he made sure to stop at appropriate places so I could take pictures. A very memorable day - one of the highlights of our trip.

Quality of Experience
Donald is a great guide, and Harris is a beautiful island.
Guides, Drivers and Staff
Donald knew the answer to all our questions, and as a lifelong Lewis resident, he was steeped in the history of the place.
Transport
Donald was on time, went long so we could see more, and told us so much.
Corrieshalloch Gorge National Nature Reserve
Corrieshalloch Gorge National Nature Reserve
Ullapool

it was hard to believe a canyon this deep is so close to Ullapool. We spent extra time here, birding and enjoying the scenery. We also had lunch at the visitor center cafe (shared outdoor picnic tables).

Quality of Experience
Loch Gruinart
Loch Gruinart
Islay

We walked through the Loch Gruinart trails a bit to quickly to find birds. Dougie knew the area well - he used to live there - and he had fascinating stories about the history. But he could have had more awareness of how birders like to walk through a preserve.

Quality of Experience
Guides, Drivers and Staff
Dougie knew the area well, but he could have paid more attention to how we would have liked to walk through the preserve.
Transport
Kilchoman Distillery Classic Tour
Kilchoman Distillery Classic Tour
Islay

A great distillery tour! Understand that I almost never say that because all distillery tours have the same core content. You get the local nuance, but the stills, fermenters, washbacks, and the like, are pretty much the same. This tour had a great guide (Darren) who was funny and knowledgeable, and it included four serious samplings of Kilchoman whisky at key places on the tour. It made it much more fun!

Quality of Experience
Guides, Drivers and Staff
Transport
We were driven to the distillery by Dougie Mac Taggert so that both my wife and I could enjoy the tasting.
Local specialist: Eleanor Whitticombe
Eleanor
Eleanor Whitticombe
Local specialist in Pembrokeshire, Wales | Replied on Sep 25, 2026
Dear Ross, Thank you for taking the time to write such a thoughtful review. It was a pleasure planning your journey through the north and west of Scotland, and hearing that it ranks among your best trips means a great deal to me. I loved reading about your days on Islay with Dougie and on Lewis and Harris with Donald. The coastal walk to Kilchoman, followed by Loch Gruinart, sounds like a particularly wonderful day. I’m glad Donald’s local knowledge made exploring the islands so enjoyable,... Read more

Dear Ross,

Thank you for taking the time to write such a thoughtful review. It was a pleasure planning your journey through the north and west of Scotland, and hearing that it ranks among your best trips means a great deal to me.

I loved reading about your days on Islay with Dougie and on Lewis and Harris with Donald. The coastal walk to Kilchoman, followed by Loch Gruinart, sounds like a particularly wonderful day. I’m glad Donald’s local knowledge made exploring the islands so enjoyable, and that you managed to take in at least some of the scenery along the B869 while navigating those single-track roads!

I’m delighted that The Dipping Lugger, The Torridon and the Isle of Eriska were highlights. Thank you, too, for the detailed hotel feedback. It’s lovely to hear what made each stay memorable, and your observations about the smaller inconveniences are helpful as I plan future trips.

I’ll share your kind words with Dougie, Donald and the rest of the team. Thank you again for trusting me with your holiday. I’m so pleased it gave you so many memories to take home.

Warm wishes,
Eleanor