Thoughtful Exploration of Komodo and Yogyakar...
Indonesia | Apr 4 - Apr 12, 2025

Owen
Owen B.
Peoria, IL | Reviewed on Apr 13, 2025

Thoughtful Exploration of Komodo and Yogyakarta, but Disjointed Planning

Our recent journey through Indonesia with KimKim featured some outstanding highlights—particularly in Komodo and Yogyakarta—but ultimately fell short of the seamless and well-curated experience we’ve come to expect from the platform.

We began in Bali, where things got off to a shaky start. Although we were met at the airport by both a guide and a driver, we were simply dropped off at our hotel with no further guidance or suggestions for the rest of the day. The following day we had a driver (who was friendly and helpful) but no guide, and were again left to plan our own itinerary. We visited Uluwatu Temple, much of which was unfortunately closed and underwhelming, and Padang Padang Beach, which was uncomfortably crowded. A stop at a luwak coffee plantation ended up being a nice surprise—albeit a bit touristy—but overall, we felt that Bali lacked the thoughtful planning and local insight we were hoping for. In hindsight, we would have preferred to skip it entirely and focus more on Komodo and Yogyakarta.

Komodo, in contrast, was a true standout. Our guide was exceptional, and the experiences—from trekking to see Komodo dragons to snorkeling with manta rays and turtles—were unforgettable. We also loved visiting waterfalls and caves, all of which felt immersive and well-curated.

Yogyakarta offered a mixed experience. Borobudur was beautiful, though we unfortunately purchased the wrong ticket and were unable to access the upper levels to view the carvings. Candi Rejo was a delightful visit, and Prambanan was another high point, enhanced by an excellent guide. The cooking class, while fun, felt somewhat underwhelming. Our visit to the Ramayana Ballet was disappointing—it felt overly touristy and amateurish, with low-quality food. Ironically, we discovered a much more authentic and high-quality ballet performance at the Kraton the following day (after our official itinerary had ended), which made us wish our original tour had included this instead. Fortunately, our local guide in Yogyakarta was incredibly knowledgeable and brought a lot of insight and depth to our experience.

While we appreciated many aspects of this trip, we felt that overall planning could have been stronger. Communication from our specialist, Marc, was inconsistent, and there seemed to be a lack of alignment between him and the local guides. We encountered several discrepancies—such as starting times that didn’t match—and often felt unclear about the daily agenda. In previous trips with KimKim, we've valued the daily suggestions and tailored support from our specialists, which were largely missing here.

More importantly, one of the reasons we turn to KimKim is for thoughtful, curated travel that helps us avoid crowds and overly touristy experiences. Unfortunately, this trip included several stops that felt like classic tourist traps. A more customized and locally-informed itinerary would have made a significant difference. With more attentive planning and better communication, this could have been a truly exceptional trip.

Hotel Reviews
Lumbini Luxury villas

Outstanding hotel although a ways from the beach. There is a shuttle although we did not try it. Private pool was outstanding.

Authenticity & Character
Felt very unique. Loved the pool.
Location
Good although not near some of the famous areas like Kuta
Staff
Friendly
Cleanliness & Comfort
Great beds, outstanding private pool
Sudamala Resort, Komodo, Labuan Bajo
Labuan Bajo

Great place although it did have a large number of families which may have been difficult for some.

Authenticity & Character
Very authentic and unique. Great food!
Location
Beautiful sunsets, not too far from town. Bay was too cloudy for snorkeling nearby.
Staff
Friendly, Amazing masseuse!
Cleanliness & Comfort
Great character, spotless
d'Omah Hotel Yogya
Sewon

Great hotel but very loud due to prayers, roosters, etc.

Authenticity & Character
Great food, Cool village life.
Location
Little bit far from the town center and sights such as borobodur and prambatan.
Staff
Friendly
Cleanliness & Comfort
Little bit worn. Sometimes felt a bit dirty. Private pool was satisfactory.
Activity Reviews
Rangko Cave
Labuan Bajo

Good but must get very busy during the summer. Did especially love the waterfall and I think it's worth the special trip. The visit to the village was so-so.

Quality of Experience
Cool Cave but could see it getting really busy during the summer.
Guides, Drivers and Staff
Outstanding Guide! Funny, charismatic, and authentic.
Transport
Great Driver, very comfy
Day tour Highlights of Komodo national Park
Day tour Highlights of Komodo national Park
Indonesia

One of the best experiences ever! Loved seeing the Komotos, the Mantas, and the turtles. Skip the Pink Beach and see if you can swim other places.

Quality of Experience
Seeing the Komodo dragons and the Mantas!
Food
Lunch was so-so.
Guides, Drivers and Staff
Amazing guide. Authentic, Charismatic, and charming
Transport
Loved the fast boat.
Borobudur: A UNESCO World Heritage Site
Borobudur: A UNESCO World Heritage Site
Yogyakarta

Beautiful and historic wonder of the world. Our guide was amazing!

Quality of Experience
Would have been nice to go inside
Guides, Drivers and Staff
Knowledgeable, great cultural insight
Transport
Easy
Experience the Ramayana Ballet
Experience the Ramayana Ballet
Yogyakarta

Very touristy and amateur. Felt like a community production. Food was poor quality, exclusively tourists, mostly large groups. Not worth going to.

Quality of Experience
Amateur and touristy
Food
Okay buffet style but not very unique.
Guides, Drivers and Staff
Not much our guide could add
Transport
Easy
Explore Traditional Javanese Villages
Explore Traditional Javanese Villages
Indonesia

Delicious lunch and a cool look into the world of the Javanese village. Did not feel exploitative. Carriage ride was cool as well.

Quality of Experience
Felt authentic
Food
Delicious
Guides, Drivers and Staff
Great guide
Transport
Easy
Prambanan: Indonesia’s Largest Shivaite Temple Complex
Prambanan: Indonesia’s Largest Shivaite Temple Complex
Yogyakarta

Outstanding with spectacular views. Cool historical bas relief carvings.

Quality of Experience
Cool to see and very special
Guides, Drivers and Staff
Amazing guide, Very knowledgeable.
Transport
Easy
Cooking class - the heart of Jogja
Cooking class - the heart of Jogja
Yogyakarta

Fun but could probably have been better.

Quality of Experience
Cool to learn cooking but did not feel quite as full as it could have been.
Food
Delicious food.
Guides, Drivers and Staff
Helpful but did not speak english, has not really taught this much before
Transport
Easy, in hotel
Local specialist: Marc Urban
Marc
Marc Urban
Local specialist in Bali | Replied on May 03, 2025
Hi Owen and friends, First of all, I want to sincerely thank you for choosing to travel with us and for taking the time to share such a detailed and thoughtful review. I truly appreciate both your kind words about the highlights of your trip and your constructive feedback regarding the areas that didn’t meet your expectations. I’d like to take this opportunity to respond to your comments—both to provide some context and, where needed, to take full responsibility for anything that could have... Read more

Hi Owen and friends,

First of all, I want to sincerely thank you for choosing to travel with us and for taking the time to share such a detailed and thoughtful review. I truly appreciate both your kind words about the highlights of your trip and your constructive feedback regarding the areas that didn’t meet your expectations. I’d like to take this opportunity to respond to your comments—both to provide some context and, where needed, to take full responsibility for anything that could have been clearer or better coordinated.

Your arrival and the first days in Bali:

I completely understand your disappointment with the initial days in Bali. These days were designed as a gentle landing after your long journey, with a driver but no guide service included, allowing you time to rest and explore at your own pace. This was outlined in the proposal and itinerary, and the listed activities were intended as suggestions. That said, I recognize that I could have done more to set expectations more clearly and offer more proactive recommendations to help you make the most of your free time.

Your visit to Uluwatu and Padang Padang:

Thank you for sharing your impressions. While these sites can be beautiful, they are often very crowded, depending on the time of day and season. I generally recommend minimizing time in South Bali’s most touristy areas (like Kuta and Seminyak).

I also want to clarify that we intentionally arranged your accommodation in Jimbaran, rather than Kuta, because Jimbaran offers a more peaceful atmosphere and retains a stronger local identity, far from the mass tourism and overdevelopment that have impacted other parts of the south.
That said, I regret not communicating this approach more explicitly. Had I known you were seeking an even more immersive cultural experience, I would have suggested a very different itinerary focused on inland traditional villages, temple ceremonies, and time with one of our cultural guides.

Komodo – a true highlight:

I'm thrilled to hear that your time in Komodo was a standout experience!

Yogyakarta – a mix of highs and areas for improvement:

Thank you for your detailed feedback. I’d like to clarify a few key points:

- Borobudur access: Current regulations around visiting the upper levels of Borobudur are indeed complex and change frequently. Your itinerary clearly stated that your ticket included access to the surrounding grounds only. This reflects a strong commitment to sustainability and heritage preservation. Although limited access to the upper levels has recently been reintroduced, it requires a special ticket with strict quotas and timed entry. We have chosen not to include this by default, to support conservation efforts and discourage last-minute add-ons that can contribute to the temple’s erosion.

- Ramayana Ballet: I’m sorry the ballet performance did not meet your expectations. I always strive to book the most authentic version available, but the venue rotates between locations such as the Prambanan Open-Air Theater, Purawisata, and occasionally the Kraton, depending on the day and season. On the date of your visit, the most authentic option was not available.

- Candi Rejo and Prambanan: I’m delighted to hear that these visits—and especially your local guide—left a positive impression. Our team is deeply passionate about their work.

Communication and itinerary adjustments:

I want to address your concerns regarding communication and alignment. When preparing trips, my philosophy is to build a structure that allows for flexibility, enabling drivers and guides to adapt to local conditions such as ceremonies, weather, or even your energy levels. In Indonesia, time and plans tend to flow a little differently, and I try to reflect that reality in how we operate. I maintain daily contact with the ground team and empower them to adjust plans when needed, always with your experience in mind. However, I completely understand that these adjustments may have felt uncoordinated without clearer real-time updates from me.

I truly value your honest feedback, and I take it to heart. My goal is always to design trips that are authentic, meaningful, and tailored to each traveler, steering away from mass tourism and offering more personalized, enriching experiences.

That’s why I always provide my direct number to all travelers. You’re welcome to text or call me anytime during your trip if you need suggestions, want to clarify details, or if anything comes up that I can help with. I want to be available to make sure your experience is as smooth and enjoyable as possible.

Thank you again for your valuable input. Despite the challenges, I hope the beauty of Indonesia—and the people you encountered along the way—left you with lasting memories.

Best wishes,
Marc