Different kimkim epxerience from Iceland but still good overall
Scotland | Oct 22 - Oct 29, 2022

J
John B.
Canada | Reviewed on Oct 30, 2022

Great trip overall. Every day something new.
The good:
Edinburgh hotel
Stirling castle
Scotch tasting tours in general
Kings hotel in Glencoe was stunning
Restaurant in Portree for tasting menu was phenomenal. 40 min drive but worth it.
Guide at Bannockburn was amazing. Super knowledgeable and a good sport.
Portree northern loop drive and hikes fantastic. One of the main hikes was closed though which was disappointing
Hike near the hotel with a hiking guide was terrific and guide was very good

The disappointing
Edinburgh guide was not from Edinburgh, had only lived there two years and was 15 minutes late.
Would have preferred a more well know whiskey set of tours. Ones we went to were either brand new or not single malt focused.
Staff at hotel in xxx didn't have our dinner paid for and didn't apologize or make up for it when our trip planner proved them wrong
Hotel in Portee was two star at best. Cold, small, run down.

Hotel Reviews
Eden Locke
Edinburgh

Good location. Tiny rooms. Great staff

Authenticity & Character
Location
Staff
Cleanliness & Comfort
Atholl Palace Hotel
Pitlochry

It's run down and staff are not local

Authenticity & Character
Location
Staff
Not friendly.
Cleanliness & Comfort
Hotel is running down. Probably very nice 20 years ago. Feels like it's run from far away with eastern European staff
Rosedale Hotel
Portree County

Run down. Small. Cold. No heat at night...needed a plug in heater. No closet. Very hard to find a parking spot.

Authenticity & Character
Kind of a dump
Location
On Harbour but limited parking was an issue
Staff
Bar and kitchen staff very friendly. Less so front deck.
Cleanliness & Comfort
Too small to be a hotel room.
Kings House Way Inn
Glencoe

Amazing location and building and views and staff

Authenticity & Character
Location
Staff
Cleanliness & Comfort
Moxy Hotel Edinburgh Airport
Newbridge

Only stayed there for location to airport

Authenticity & Character
Trying way too hard to be cool.
Location
Staff
Waited for 7 minutes before anybody came to front deck to check us in
Cleanliness & Comfort
Beds hard a rocks and for some reason the pillows are so big that both our necks hurt the next day
Activity Reviews
Private walking tour of Edinburgh with a top local guide
Private walking tour of Edinburgh with a top local guide
Edinburgh

She showed up late. Not from Edinburgh so it was authentic

Guides, Drivers and Staff
Exceptional Visit and Tasting at Blair Athol Distillery
Exceptional Visit and Tasting at Blair Athol Distillery
Pitlochry

Good tour although it's mostly there to produce a blend and not enough variety of single malt. Nor do they sell in duty free so we couldn't but anything.

Quality of Experience
Guides, Drivers and Staff
Transport
Isle of Skye Whisky immersion at Torabhaig
Isle of Skye Whisky immersion at Torabhaig
Scotland

Stunning location and buildings but they are new so not sure why we even were there. Only one wiskey to try in the "tasting". Also doesn't sell in duty free

Quality of Experience
Too new. Only one to taste
Guides, Drivers and Staff
Transport
Phd level guided tour of Bannockburn
Phd level guided tour of Bannockburn
Stirling

Get Dr David if you can A PHD in archeology and super knowledgeable about Bannockburn 3 hours tour. Lots of walking. It was great.

Quality of Experience
Guides, Drivers and Staff
Transport
A Tasting Menu at The Three Chimneys
A Tasting Menu at The Three Chimneys
Scotland

Awesome food. Chef tablets way to go. Book well well in advance

Quality of Experience
Guides, Drivers and Staff
Transport
Middle of nowhere and 40 minutes drive so someone has to be designated driver in the dark and rainy drive home
Private guided walk in Glencoe
Private guided walk in Glencoe
Scotland

Great guide. Good hike mostly uphill but perfect if in shape but still not a hiker.

Quality of Experience
Guides, Drivers and Staff
Transport
Local specialist: Stephen Molloy
Stephen
Stephen Molloy
Local specialist in Dorset and Lyon | Replied on Nov 04, 2022
Hi John I am really happy to read that you and your three travel companions had a great trip overall to Scotland! I must say I enjoyed reading your news by SMS during the trip too. I fondly remember the Zoom we had pre-trip too, and I am happy that you enjoyed yourselves. I am also very happy to hear that you loved our speciality guides at Bannockburn and Glencoe! The Trotternish Peninsula drive is amazing and I am happy that you took our advice and did that loop. What a shame that a hike... Read more

Hi John

I am really happy to read that you and your three travel companions had a great trip overall to Scotland! I must say I enjoyed reading your news by SMS during the trip too. I fondly remember the Zoom we had pre-trip too, and I am happy that you enjoyed yourselves. I am also very happy to hear that you loved our speciality guides at Bannockburn and Glencoe! The Trotternish Peninsula drive is amazing and I am happy that you took our advice and did that loop. What a shame that a hike was closed in late October! The Three Chimneys Restaurant is one of the top places to dine in the UK and I am really happy that you loved the Kitchen Tasting experience. I am sure you forged strong memories with your friends there. The question of transport was raised with you beforehand, and you did not take it up – yes, instead a local driver could be used for 60£ each way.

I am sorry to hear that the Edinburgh guide was late, they explained to me it was because of an event in Edinburgh that they could not navigate through quickly. I am sorry about that. We have noted what you said and will certainly not use them again.

Sorry to hear that the hotel in Pitlochry did not immediately honour our payment about dinner. It is perhaps an indication of a broken line of communication between Kitchen to Reception to Finance.

When it comes to the hotel in Portree, well we have chosen this in the past on occasion because of the views and the location. It is certainly not as high-end as the wonderful Cuillin Hills hotel around the corner, but the budget did not allow this. We will certainly never send anyone here in the somewhat chilly month of October! Thank you for letting us know.

Thank you for your time and choosing us. Thank you for this detailed feedback too!
Stephen